[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: .africa gTLD



Martin J. Duerst wrote:

> I sincerely hope that the maintainer, signing as "Fred Gregoire",
> is not Swiss, and that he doesn't operate from Switzerland.

No, he is not Swiss and he doesn't seem to operate from Switzerland.
as suggested by the four Whois Query Results below.

Whois Query Results for 
- .bi (Burundi)
- .cg (Congo) 
- .rw (Rwanda)
- .zr (Zaire) country TLDs

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Burundi Republic of top-level domain BI4-DOM
   IBPT - Connectivite au reseau Internet
   Avenue des Etats-Unis - B.P. 4732
   Bujumbura,
   BI

   Domain Name: BI

   Administrative Contact, Billing Contact:
      Kayijuka, Fabien  FK258  admin@IBPT.BI
      + 257 222 711
   Technical Contact, Zone Contact:
      Gregoire, Fred  FG301  frg@IZPT.ZR
      + 243 12 24 222 (FAX) + 243 12 92 144

   Record last updated on 21-Oct-96.
   Record created on 21-Oct-96.

   Domain servers in listed order:

   DNS.IZPT.ZR                  193.210.151.74
   SUNIC.SUNET.SE               192.36.125.2 192.36.148.18
   PRINCETON.EDU                128.112.128.1

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Congo top-level domain CG6-DOM
   ICPT - Connectivite au reseau Internet
   Avenue Amilcar Cabral
   Brazzaville,
   CG

   Domain Name: CG

   Administrative Contact, Billing Contact:
      Nsinga, Andre  AN576  admin@ICPT.CG
      + 242 83 20 40
   Technical Contact, Zone Contact:
      Gregoire, Fred  FG301  frg@IZPT.ZR
      + 243 12 24 222 (FAX) + 243 12 92 144

   Record last updated on 14-Jan-97.
   Record created on 14-Jan-97.

   Domain servers in listed order:

   DNS.IZPT.ZR                  193.210.151.74
   SUNIC.SUNET.SE               192.36.125.2 192.36.148.18
   PRINCETON.EDU                128.112.128.1

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Rwanda Republic of top-level domain RW6-DOM
   IRPT - Connectivite au reseau Internet
   Boulevard de la Revolution - B.P. 378
   Kigali,
   RW

   Domain Name: RW

   Administrative Contact, Billing Contact:
      Karekezi, Aimable  AK1112  admin@IRPT.RW
      + 250 72 090 (FAX) + 250 72 490
   Technical Contact, Zone Contact:
      Gregoire, Fred  FG301  frg@IZPT.ZR
      + 243 12 24 222 (FAX) + 243 12 92 144

   Record last updated on 21-Oct-96.
   Record created on 21-Oct-96.

   Domain servers in listed order:

   DNS.IZPT.ZR                  193.210.151.74
   SUNIC.SUNET.SE               192.36.125.2 192.36.148.18
   PRINCETON.EDU                128.112.128.1

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Zaire Republic of top-level domain ZR2-DOM
   IZPT - Connectivite au reseau Internet
   Boulevard du Trente Juin - B.P. 8854
   Kinshasa 1
   ZR

   Domain Name: ZR

   Administrative Contact, Billing Contact:
      Zola, Matenda  MZ298  admin@IZPT.ZR
      + 243 12 24 222 (FAX) + 243 12 92 144
   Technical Contact, Zone Contact:
      Gregoire, Fred  FG301  frg@IZPT.ZR
      + 243 12 24 222 (FAX) + 243 12 92 144

   Record last updated on 03-Oct-96.
   Record created on 26-Sep-96.

   Domain servers in listed order:

   DNS.IZPT.ZR                  193.210.151.74
   SUNIC.SUNET.SE               192.36.125.2 192.36.148.18
   PRINCETON.EDU                128.112.128.1

----------------------------------------------------------------------------


Comments: All four TLDs have 
- the same primary and secondary servers.
- the same Technical Contact, Zone Contact.
- the registrant's are practically the same and the subheading is
identical in all four cases.

The http://www.izpt.zr/ home page publishes the email address of Fred
Gregoire the Technical Contact, not that of the Administrative Contact,
Billing Contact!!!

Fred Gregoie is thus "the person who has aquired the 'rw' TLD" and whom
Mark J. Elkins <mje@mje99.posix.co.za> has asked to "return it to
Rwanda". Now it looks like restitution TLD name would be due other
countries as well.

This situation is strange and leads to several questions:
- Are the governments of these four countries aware of what's going on?
- Do they approve it?
- Are the secondary servers administrators in Sweden and at Princeton
(NJ) aware of the astronomical fees charged for this name registration
service.
- Should the Internet community, through IANA, ISOC, IAHC, investigate
this situation? 


Denis Bucher wrote

> Just look at the PRICES at http://www.izpt.zr/, and you'll understand !!!

Martin J. Duerst wrote
> This is a major rip-off. 550 Swiss Francs for initial registration,
> and 350 Swiss Francs for one-year renewal. For those who don't know
> what a Swiss Franc is worth, currently that makes ~400$ for registration,
> and 260$ for renewal. There is also a "name reservation" fee, not much
> lower, just for reserving a domain name. 

This is particular true for countries where per capita income is less
than $400/yr. DNS registration becomes de facto a elite service out of
reach for entrepreneurs, researchers, faculty, etc. and all other
potential and legitimate users. By the same token, the Internet falls
victim of the same paradox as telephony, which is less expensive in the
wealthy United States than in poor Africa.