Re: Judge Defers AlterNIC Action

[Jeff Williams <jwkckid1@ix.netcom.com>]

Marc and all,

  I am afraid that for the most part what Marc has said here is nearly
right on the mark.  Pardon the pun there Marc!  >;)

  The biggest problem that I see as do others all over the world is
what Marc said here.  The MoU does nto scale to our culture.  I would
add that it doesn't scale to any culture that I can see.  It doesn't
meet the needs and demands of the CURRENT international buisness
community or a large portion of the user community.

  As Marc said, there are parts of the MoU that are very good.  And I 
have in the past pointed out some of those points, so i won't go over
them again now.  But the intractability of the gTLD-MoU folks seems
to be another major stumbling block that must be changed.  If not
I fear, that some of the good in the MoU may be in jepordy, which would
be a shame.

  I would encourage once again, for everyone to LISTEN to all points
with an open mind.  In that way, we all can I believe, solve the 
DNS system concerns and known problems.  Sueing someone like Eugene
as the NSI has done will not make for possitive results, only entrench.
This is NOT a solution or an method of obtaining one.


Marc Hurst wrote:
> 
> Working within North America I get to work personally with the Flemings',
> the Sextons', the Denningers, the Fenellos', the Kleinmans' and the Eugenes.
> 
> I've been to the conferences and met the other stakeholders including the
> Rutowskys' and the Amblers'.
> 
> The IANA model is broken. The US guv isn't supporting it, the Canadian
> guv isn't supporting it and even the Canadian Industry doesn't support it
> and can't support it because it does not scale to our culture.
> 
> These are serious flaws. Where were you when the newdom list was alive
> and kicking last summer? I preached that international interests must be
> recognised and when the MoU came out these issues were (and still are)
> absent.
> 
> Don't be sold a broken model. I don't disagreed with the entire Mou, but
> there are some fundamental problems that need to be changed.
> 
> Marc

Regards,
-- 
Jeffrey A. Williams
DIR. Internet Network Eng/SR. Java Development Eng.
Information Eng. Group. IEG. INC. 
Phone :913-294-2375 (v-office)
E-Mail jwkckid1@ix.netcom.com