( BW)(CORE)
WASHINGTON--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Jan. 30, 1998--The Internet
Council of Registrars
(CORE) said the Green Paper released today by the U.S. Department of
Commerce provides a
step in the right direction to ending the U.S. stewardship over the
domain name system and opening
the Internet to self-governance and international competition.
However, some of the proposed steps appear to add
new levels of U.S. government regulation
for an undetermined amount of time. This could perpetuate the existing
monopoly and slow the
transition to competition and self-governance, based on an initial
evaluation by a panel of CORE
executives and Internet experts from around the world.
"A quick reading of this draft indicates there are
several areas the U.S., CORE and the
international Internet community agree on," said Alan Hanson, chairman
of the executive committee
of CORE. "The first and most important is empowering the Internet Assigned
Numbers Authority
(IANA) to continue to serve as overall manager of the Root zone. IANA
has been making policy
decisions for years and can continue to do so while the new IANA corporation
is established.
"Many CORE members throughout the world are concerned
the proposed policy overlooks the
international nature of the Internet. The Green Paper appears to carve
out a U.S.-centric process
designed to better serve the vested interests of Network Solutions
rather than the broader interests
of the world Internet community."
CORE members were encouraged that the Green Paper
had included many concepts from its
generic Top Level Domain Memo of Understanding (gTLD-MoU). "There are
many technical
details that have been covered in the Green Paper but none of the ethical
ones," Hanson said. "As
we go forward, CORE will continue to promote international cooperation
on this issue and ongoing
stewardship of the public trust. Self-governance and self-determination
are key issues to be
pursued to better serve the world Internet community."
CORE international members found additional concerns
about the potential for U.S.
micro-management of the process, without international input.
"A key question needs to be answered: how to shorten
the long and possibly bumpy road on the
U.S. exit strategy?" Hanson said.
Many of the issues raised in the Green Paper have
been addressed and resolved through the
CORE process over the past 15 months. The U.S. government paper outlines
the reasons for "The
Need for Change." CORE supports six of the seven points and provides
answers to most,
including: adding competition to domain name registration, establishing
a mechanism for resolving
conflict between trademark holders and domain name holders, recognizing
the growing percentage
of users outside the U.S. and giving them a larger voice in the process,
developing a system that is
accountable to the Internet community, and supporting the evolution
of the Internet as a commercial
medium.
"The draft discusses the Administration's proposed
transition from government oversight to
private enterprise and largely outlines a process already completed
by the International Ad Hoc
Committee (IAHC), the Policy Oversight Board (POC), and CORE to develop
competition,"
according to David Maher, chairman of POC. "The paper envisions a board
of directors for the
new corporation that is very much like the POC and CORE boards - drawn
from stakeholders
around the world. It describes a model for open and fair corporate
processes that replicates the
exact steps taken by IAHC to develop the gTLD Memo of Understanding
(gTLD-MoU), which
established rules and procedures for the evolution of POC and CORE
to administer domain name
registrations."
Other areas in the Green Paper that have been addressed
through the long POC and CORE
process include: promoting competition among registrars; establishing
a fast and efficient system
through an independent world organization for resolving trademark disputes;
and establishing
standards for all participants.
"The Green Paper calls for the creation of up to
five new registries, each of which would be
given one new gTLD," said Hanson. "CORE has been working more than
15 months through a
global process to create a Shared Registry System to manage seven gTLDs.
Jon Postel, head of
IANA, and other technical experts have assured us, that adding new
-- up to a hundred TLDs is
trivial. The system is sound. There should be no concerns about stability
and no need to drag out
the transition process.
"As of today, we believe CORE is the only organization
that can accomplish most of the
organizational functions outlined in the Green Paper, while meeting
the technical and management
qualifications outlined in Appendix 1 for Recommended Registry and
Registrar Requirements."
When additional acceptance testing of the CORE SRS
is completed in two weeks, CORE will
be prepared to go live immediately with a proven, tested worldwide
system for registering names.
CORE and its expert advisors and suppliers also designed the system
for instant, ongoing analysis
of all aspects of the operation. This can satisfy the Administration's
interest in evaluating the effects
on the addition of new gTLDs.
"CORE is ready now to demonstrate the ease of adding
up to seven new TLDs to the Root --
with no impact on stability and a quantum leap in competition and customer
service," said Hanson,
CORE chairman. "In a very short amount of time, this will give the
Administration the data
necessary to speed the transition process to a non-profit corporation
far ahead of the 2000
timetable.
"We will formally respond to the Green Paper and
ask the Administration to move forward
quickly with the CORE model and system. The goal: to provide rapid
proof that the addition of
more new competitive registries and registrars can be accomplished
quickly and safely, thereby
achieving the President's direction to privatize, increase competition
and promote international
participation in the domain name system as rapidly as possible."
In addition to supporting several key U.S. Government
concepts based on its initial reading of
the Green Paper, CORE reiterated its key positions on the steps it
feels are essential toward
deregulation:
- Continuing recognition of IANA's full authority for domain name system decisions.
- Support for transferring IANA to status as a new
non-profit U.S. corporation over the next
three to six months at the latest.
- Support for IANA maintaining physical control and authority over the root zone contents.
- Giving IANA the immediate authority to manage the
short-term details of the transition during
the U.S. Government's exit strategy.
- Opening domain name registration to new generic
Top Level Domains immediately, with IANA
determining the schedule based on technical criteria and the qualifications
of proposed registries or
registrars, similar to the criteria established for CORE registrars.
- Encouraging the expansion of multiple shared registrars
to ensure the continued growth and
vitality of the Internet as a global resource.
- Embracing the process established through the Arbitration
and Mediation Center at the World
Intellectual Property Organization to provide trademark and domain
name owners with a means of
resolving disputes quickly and inexpensively.
- Understanding that litigation is inevitable in
today's society, whatever the final plan; it is essential
that the transition move forward rapidly and in good faith to the ultimate
benefit of the most users.
- Using the process outlined in the gTLD-MoU to encourage
ongoing broader international
participation in the self-governance and expansion of the Internet
"The Internet needs to move quickly to international
self-governance because demand for new
domain names from outside the U.S. is growing exponentially," said
Hanson. "It would be a
disservice to the world Internet community to create artificial limitations
on competition and growth
in the short-term under the proposed plan to regulate the transition
to deregulation. President
Clinton, in his state of the union message, even talked about the Internet
getting clogged."
CORE will begin preparing its detailed response to
the Green Paper immediately, based on input
from throughout the world.
"In terms of registering names, until there are final
decisions by the U.S. Government, CORE will
continue with its preparations to begin serving Internet users throughout
the world while doing
whatever is necessary to speed up the transition process to self-governance
and competition," said
Hanson. "The Green Paper has established a good starting point and
we look forward to working
with the White House to move quickly to the new era of self-governance."
ABOUT CORE
The long process toward self-governance began in
late 1995 when NSI was allowed to begin
charging for registering domains, a service that had previously been
free. The Internet community
was upset, but there was no recourse because NSI was a monopoly. A
plan proposed by Jon
Postel, head of the IANA, sought to break the monopoly and add up to
150 Top Level Domains
to the Internet. He presented his concepts to the Internet Society
(ISOC) and their joint efforts led
to the formation of the International Ad Hoc Committee, which launched
a rigorous public process
in fall 1996 to solve the logjam and lead the Internet toward self-governance.
CORE and the Policy Oversight Committee (POC) evolved
from this process and have
developed protocols, procedures, systems and software to administer
competitive domain
registration. CORE has been privately financed and developed with global
consensus. It is nearing
completion of a turnkey share registry system with working infrastructure,
well-defined operating
standards and a dedicated membership.
As a result of this rigorous process and quality
of input from many sources and interests, the
CORE model has drawn widespread support from the Internet community,
major corporations and
organizations worldwide.
Key signatories to the Memo of Understanding for
the POC and CORE include Digital
Equipment Corporation (DEC), MCI, Bell Canada, the Internet Policy
Oversight Committee
(POC), the Internet Society (ISOC), the Internet Assigned Names Authority
(IANA), the World
Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO), the European Telecommunications
Standard Institute,
France Telecom, the International Trademark Association and the Internet
Society of Australia.
CORE currently lists 88 registrars in 23 countries,
including 25 U.S. registrars with a presence in
103 American cities. It plans to begin accepting applications from
potential new registrars
immediately under a process outlined in the generic Top Level Domain-Memorandum
of
Understanding (gTLD-MOU). Applicants must meet the same financial and
technical requirements
as the current registrars. Applications will be audited by an independent
third party to be chosen in
the near future.
For further information, see the CORE Web site at www.gtld-mou.org .
--30--NG/sd KRH/sd
CONTACT: The Gable Group
Tom Gable (tomg@gablegroup.com)
Dianne Gleason (dianne@gablegroup.com)
619/234-1300
or
Susan Davis International
Judy Whittlesey (judithhw@aol.com)
Clarkson Hine (cchine@aol.com)
Catharine Dickey
Sheila O'Neil
202/408-0808
KEYWORD: DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CALIFORNIA
INDUSTRY KEYWORD: INTERACTIVE/MULTIMEDIA/INTERNET
GOVERNMENT